Forms of Legalism

 Forms of legalism.


It is critical to understand that legalism and obedience to the Law are not equal. Biblically speaking, legalism isn't using the law, but the wrong use of the law. Just like antinomianism (anti-law), legalism can take many forms.  


  1. Justification based on works of merit or obedience to the Law

This is the error of the Pharisees and Pelagianism (Humans can obtain perfection without divine grace). The semi-pelagian view that grace mixed with works can justify (Roman Catholics, Mormonism) would also fall into this category.

Response: All men are sinners and have broken God's law (Rom 3:10, 23). Because of this, the Law cannot save them, it can only condemn them as lawbreakers who deserve the full penalty under the Law. (Rom 3:19-20, Gal 3:10) The only hope for transgressors of God's Law is salvation by grace in the work of Jesus Christ.  


  1. Stressing the letter of the Law, while neglecting the spirit in which it was given

This attitude usually stresses observing the minute details of the Law, (which is what Christ commands) but neglects the “weightier matters of the Law” (Mat 23:23). This legalist fails to give mercy to others, fails to give true justice and does not love God from a heart of faith. This also was a Pharisaical error. 

Response: We must stress careful obedience and conformity to God's standards, and call all men to serve God from the heart in the spirit of love and submission. True obedience requires both outward conformity and inward submission. (Psalms 119:34) Purely outward obedience fails the test of true obedience. (Matt 5:17-6:18) True obedience begins in the heart and is motivated by love. 


  1. Failure to emphasize the centrality of the Holy Spirit in sanctification

In this view the law is given the power to sanctify; all one needs to do is apply himself to keeping the law and he will become righteous in all his actions and attitudes. 

Response: However, the law as a written code of moral conduct, does not have the power to sanctify the believer. The Law can command the way of righteousness, but it cannot supply the motivation or desire to walk in righteousness. (2 Cor 3:6, Rom 7:6-26) It is the Holy Spirit alone who can enable the believer to fulfill the requirements of the Law. (Rom 8:2-4) The law is critical in our sanctification, but only as the instrument of the Holy Spirit to reprove, correct and lead us in righteousness. 


  1. Adding human traditions to God's Law

Traditions which are supposedly based on God's law, set up human standards of righteousness, yet they actually nullify God's standards, leading men to transgress the true commands of God. (Mat 15:1-9) These commandments of men are used by the self-righteous to exalt themselves and condemn others who do not abide by their traditions.

Response: Human traditions either add or take away from the righteous standards of God's Law. All such meddling and tampering with God's Law is strictly forbidden. (Deut 4:12, 12:32)
Christianity has no place for legalistic tradition, the commands of God should be the final standard

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Natural Law: Seeker Sensitive Jurisprudence

Image
Theonomy or Autonomy. I’ve heard it many times. The implication is simple. Either you acknowledge and strive to follow and understand God's Law (as revealed in the Bible), or you reject God's Laws in favor of man's opinions, methods of justice, morality, and lawgiving. For many, the line is clearly drawn in the sand. Theonomists are quickly and easily identified because of the name that is applied to their position (theos=God, nomos=Law). There is room for differences and debate within this position, but ultimately all theonomists seek one thing: to properly and accurately apply God's revealed Law to all spheres of life, including Civil.  Autonomy on the other hand, can take many forms and names: Socialism, Democracy, Feudalism, Dictatorship, Sharia, with many more options available. (I will state here that all law is a form of moral system, even if it isn’t religious. So while all these Autonomous options are seen as political, they also have moral systems inherent to
Read more

Top 3 reasons why you shouldn't be a Theonomist

Image
  The rise of Theonomy and Dominionism among a growing segment of modern Christianity is cause for concern. More and more people are being seduced by these unbiblical beliefs and are marching toward a expectation and future that simply can't be supported when you look around at the world today.  The appeal to an abrogated Old Testament is especially bad. Jesus taught regularly that the adherence to the Old Law was "leaven" and taught that love had superseded the violent and insensitive laws of the Old Order.  Since this theology is becoming so prevalent, with new interests in theonomy and republishing of out-of-print book such as "Theonomy in Christian Ethics" I decided that I needed to show the top 3 reasons why you should avoid theonomy.  1) It depends too much on scripture. Theonomists are far too dependent upon the word of God to be trusted. Whenever you try and bring an objection against them they typically respond with a bible verse. This can usually be re
Read more

What About the Narrow Way?

Image
An extremely common objection to the optimistic view of Postmillennialism (the view that the Gospel will be victorious in the conversion of mankind and that the world will be largely converted by the second advent) is the passage that speaks of the narrow way. The assumption made in this objection is that this passage speaks of an extremely limited number of mankind that will actually be saved in the scope of history. This text is used in a prophetically biased way that applies this text to all of mankind for all of time. I think that if we examine this passage carefully, we will see that it is actually better proof for a Postmillennial view. First, let's look at the main passage: Then one said to Him, "Lord, are there few who are saved?" And He said to them, "Strive to enter through the narrow gate, for many, I say to you, will seek to enter and will not be able. "When once the Master of the house has risen up and shut the door, and you begin to stand outside
Read more